Charitable Deductions by State

by Erica York, Tax Foundation, December 20, 2018

As the end of 2018 approaches, many Americans are considering making end-of-year charitable donations. While the new tax law contains many changes that will impact these decisions, we can look at Internal Revenue Service (IRS) data to gauge how much Americans have deducted for charitable giving in the past.

In tax year 2016, just over 37 million taxpayers took an itemized deduction for their charitable giving, deducting a total of $236 billion in charitable contributions for an average of $6,349. Note that this doesn’t represent the total amount of giving in the United States, just the amount that eligible taxpayers deducted on their income tax returns. It’s also worth noting that wealthier Americans disproportionately benefit from the charitable deduction overall, as it is high-income taxpayers who tend to itemize their deductions.

Four states had average charitable deductions greater than $10,000 in 2016: Wyoming ($12,991), Arkansas ($10,935), Utah ($10,165), and South Dakota ($10,019). The state with the smallest average, at $3,354, was Rhode Island.

Because the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act greatly increased the standard deduction, it’s estimated that nearly 30 million households will be better off taking the standard deduction instead of itemizing. While this means tax filing will be simpler, it also means these households will no longer benefit from the charitable contribution deduction.

Lower marginal tax rates under the new law also mean that, for those still taking itemized deductions, their value is lessened. While charitable giving will still be subsidized for these taxpayers, it will be subsidized to a lesser extent.

As millions fewer households will itemize going forward, we should expect forthcoming IRS data to show fewer charitable contribution deductions. What this means for charitable giving overall, however, is less certain. Though some households may decrease their giving, others may use new strategies, such as bunching their donations, or maintaining their giving by making multiple years’ worth of donations at once to have enough to itemize. Given that the tax subsidy for charitable donations has decreased, it would not be surprising if tax-motivated charitable giving decreases as well. However, households make giving decisions for a variety of reasons, many of which are not tax related.

Hawaii

• 48 -- Rank
• 163,170 -- Number of Charitable Deductions
• $671 -- Amount of Charitable Deductions (in millions)
• $4,111.80 -- Average Charitable Deduction