24 Percent of U.S. County Housing Markets Less Affordable Than Their Historic Norms in Q3 2016
IRVINE, Calif. – Sept. 29, 2016 — ATTOM Data Solutions, the nation’s leading source for comprehensive housing data and the new parent company of RealtyTrac, today released its Q3 2016 Home Affordability Index, which shows that 24 percent of U.S. county housing markets were less affordable than their historic affordability averages in the third quarter, up from 22 percent of markets in the previous quarter and up from 19 percent of markets a year ago to the highest share of since Q3 2009 — when 47 percent of markets were less affordable than their historic affordability averages.
The report analyzed median home prices derived from publicly recorded sales deed data collected by ATTOM Data Solutions and average wage data from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics in 414 U.S. counties with a combined population of more than 203 million. The affordability index is based on the percentage of average wages needed to make monthly house payments on a median-priced home with a 30-year fixed rate and a 3 percent down payment — including property taxes and insurance.
The report also breaks out county-level closing costs, using settlement service rates, transfer taxes and recording fees by ClosingCorp (see full methodology below).
Counties in Houston, Brooklyn, Dallas less affordable than their historic norms
Out of the 414 counties analyzed in the report, 101 counties (24 percent) had an affordability index below 100 in the third quarter of 2016, meaning that buying a median-priced home in that county was less affordable than the historic average for that county going back to the first quarter of 2005.
Counties less affordable than their historic averages in Q3 2016 included Harris County (Houston), Texas; Kings County (Brooklyn), New York; Dallas County, Texas; Bexar County (San Antonio), Texas; and Alameda County, California in the San Francisco metro area.
“Affordability is always a challenge for buyers and with the recent appreciation we have been experiencing we are seeing a gap in the entry-level market that in past markets was met by attached dwellings (condos),” said Greg Smith, owner/broker at RE/MAX Alliance, covering the Denver market, where all five counties included in the report were less affordable than their historic norms. Smith noted that the state’s condo-defect law has hobbled new construction of condos during the housing recovery. “As a result of builder’s risk and some predatory practices of attorneys, builders do not feel comfortable providing this product and as a result many first time buyers are finding it hard to enter the market, which can cause some ripples across the market as a whole.”
Counties still affordable by historic standards included Los Angeles County, California; Cook County (Chicago), Illinois; Maricopa County (Phoenix), Arizona; Miami-Dade County, Florida; and Queens County, New York.
“The improving affordability trend we noted in our second quarter report reversed course in the third quarter as home price appreciation accelerated in the majority of markets and wage growth slowed in the majority of local markets as well as nationwide, where average weekly wages declined in the first quarter of this year following 13 consecutive quarters with year-over-year increases,” said Daren Blomquist, senior vice president at ATTOM Data Solutions. “This unhealthy combination resulted in worsening affordability in 63 percent of markets despite mortgage rates that are down 45 basis points from a year ago.
“Some silver lining in this report is that affordability actually improved in some of the highest-priced markets that have been bastions of bad affordability, mostly the result of annual home price appreciation slowing to low single-digit percentages in those markets” Blomquist continued. “This is an indication that home prices are finally responding to affordability constraints — a modicum of good news for prospective buyers who have been priced out of those high-priced markets.”
Affordability improves in 37 percent of markets compared to year ago
Affordability improved in 153 counties (37 percent) compared to a year ago, including in the bellwether high-priced markets of Marin County, California in the San Francisco Bay Area (1 percent improvement); Santa Clara County (San Jose), California (3 percent improvement); Kings County (Brooklyn), New York (5 percent improvement); Arlington County, Virginia in the DC metro area (5 percent improvement); and Maui County, Hawaii (1 percent improvement).
Affordability worsened in 261 counties (63 percent) compared to a year ago, including Los Angeles County, California (2 percent worse); Harris County (Houston), Texas (3 percent worse); Maricopa County (Phoenix), Arizona (3 percent worse); Miami-Dade County, Florida (5 percent worse); Queens County, New York (1 percent worse); and King County (Seattle), Washington (2 percent worse).
“While the data suggests that the counties that make up the greater Seattle area can still be considered technically ‘affordable,’ I believe that this offers a somewhat skewed perspective of what’s really taking place in our market,” said Matthew Gardner, chief economist at Windermere Real Estate, covering the Seattle housing market. “Seattle home prices correlate directly to commute times, and given the pervasive lack of transit infrastructure in our region, that means homes with reasonable access to the city are seeing aggressive price growth. Affordability remains an issue in the region, and that is unlikely to change in the foreseeable future.”
Home price growth outpaced wage growth in 89 percent of counties
Annual growth in median home prices outpaced annual growth in average weekly wages in 368 of the 414 counties analyzed (89 percent). That was a reversal from the trend in previous quarters, when the share of counties with home price growth outpacing wage growth dropped as low as 58 percent in Q2 2016.
Counties where home price growth outpaced wage growth included Los Angeles County, California; Cook County (Chicago), Illinois; Harris County (Houston); Texas; Maricopa County (Phoenix), Arizona; and San Diego County, California.
Counties where wage growth outpaced home price growth — counter to the national trend — included Clayton County (Atlanta), Georgia; Woodbury County (Sioux City), Iowa; Comal County (San Antonio), Texas; Stafford County (Washington, D.C.), Virginia; and Peoria County, Illinois.
Home prices have increased 10 times faster than wages since 2012
Across the 414 counties, the average annual change in average weekly wages was -0.1 percent while the average annual change in median home sales prices was 7 percent. Since bottoming out in Q1 2012, median home prices nationwide have risen 60 percent while average weekly wages have risen 6 percent during that same time period.
Brooklyn, Santa Cruz, San Francisco top least affordable markets by share of wages
On average across the 414 counties analyzed, average wage earners need to spend 36.3 percent of their income to buy a median-priced home, still below the historic average of 38.8 percent but up from 35.9 percent in the previous quarter and up from 35.8 percent a year ago.
Counties that were least affordable by this absolute affordability standard were Kings County (Brooklyn), New York (123.5 percent of average wages needed to buy a median priced home); Santa Cruz County, California (111.1 percent); Marin County (San Francisco), California (109.4 percent); New York County (Manhattan), New York (96.6 percent); San Luis Obispo County, California (91.2 percent).
Other counties in the top 10 least affordable were San Francisco County, California (89.6 percent); Maui County, Hawaii (89.3 percent); Napa County, California (84.1 percent); Queens County, New York (83.7 percent); and Monterey County, California (83.5 percent).
Counties that were most affordable by this absolute standard were Clayton County (Atlanta), Georgia (10.1 percent of average wages needed to buy a median-priced home); Rock Island County, Illinois (13.3 percent); Trumbull County (Youngstown), Ohio (15.2 percent); Saginaw County, Michigan (15.4 percent); and Bibb County (Macon), Georgia (15.6 percent).
read … Full Report
TEXT "follow HawaiiFreePress" to 40404
Register to Vote
808 Silent Majority
Aloha Pregnancy Care Center
Antonio Gramsci Reading List
A Place for Women in Waipio
Back da Blue Hawaii
Build More Hawaiian Homes Working Group
Christian Homeschoolers of Hawaii
Cliff Slater's Second Opinion
Frontline: The Fixers
Genetic Literacy Project
Hawaii Aquarium Fish Report
Hawaii Aviation Preservation Society
Hawaii Catholic TV
Hawaii Christian Coalition
Hawaii Cigar Association
Hawaii ConCon Info
Hawaii Debt Clock
Hawaii Defense Foundation
Hawaii Family Forum
Hawaii Farmers and Ranchers United
Hawaii Farmer's Daughter
Hawaii Federalist Society
Hawaii Federation of Republican Women
Hawaii History Blog
Hawaii Homeschool Association
Hawaii Jihadi Trial
Hawaii Legal News
Hawaii Legal Short-Term Rental Alliance
Hawaii's Partnership for Appropriate & Compassionate Care
Hawaii Public Charter School Network
Hawaii Rifle Association
Hawaii Shippers Council
Hawaii Smokers Alliance
Hawaii State Data Lab
Hiram Fong Papers
Homeschool Legal Defense Hawaii
Honolulu Navy League
House Minority Blog
Inouye-Kwock, NYT 1992
Inside the Nature Conservancy
Investigative Project on Terrorism
July 4 in Hawaii
Keep Hawaii's Heroes
Land and Power in Hawaii
Legislative Committee Analysis Tool
Lessons in Firearm Education
Managed Care Matters -- Hawaii
Malama Pregnancy Center of Maui
Military Home Educators' Network Oahu
Missile Defense Advocacy
MIS Veterans Hawaii
National Christian Foundation Hawaii
National Parents Org Hawaii
NFIB Hawaii News
No GMO Means No Aloha
Not Dead Yet, Hawaii
Oahu Alternative Transport
Opt Out Today
Patients Rights Council Hawaii
People vs Machine
Rental by Owner Awareness Assn
ReRoute the Rail
Research Institute for Hawaii USA
Rick Hamada Show
Robotics Organizing Committee
School Choice in Hawaii
Sink the Jones Act
Statehood for Guam
Tax Foundation of Hawaii
The Real Hanabusa
Time Out Honolulu
Trustee Akina KWO Columns
US Tax Foundation Hawaii Info
West Maui Taxpayers Association
What Natalie Thinks
Whole Life Hawaii