Tuesday, April 07, 2020
Hawai'i Free Press

Current Articles | Archives

Monday, October 05, 2009
Indecision in Afghanistan Costs Lives
By Heritage Foundation @ 11:10 AM :: 6147 Views :: National News, Ethics, World News, Family

Last week, upon arriving in Copenhagen for his failed mission to secure the 2016 Olympic Games for Chicago, President Barack Obama met face-to-face with U.S. and NATO Forces Commander in Afghanistan Gen. Stanley McChrystal on Air Force One. The meeting was just the second conversation between the two since Gen. McChrystal assumed command of what President Obama used to call the “central front in our enduring struggle against terrorism.” Just days before, while responding to questions about his recommendation for 40,000 more troops, Gen. McChrystal told the International Institute for Strategic Studies, “Waiting does not prolong a favorable outcome. This effort will not remain winnable indefinitely, nor will public support.”

President Obama’s advisers were “shocked and angered” by “the bluntness” of McChrystal’s speech with one White House source offering: “People aren’t sure whether McChrystal is being naïve or an upstart. To my mind he doesn’t seem ready for this Washington hard-ball and is just speaking his mind too plainly.” McChrystal may not know Washington politics, but he has impeccable credentials when it comes to military strategy. And on military strategy, Gen. McChrystal also said this last week:

I absolutely believe that al Qaeda and the threat of al Qaeda and Taliban senior leadership are critical to stability in the region…But I also believe that a strategy that does not leave Afghanistan in a stable position is probably a shortsighted strategy.

Gen. McChrystal is far from the only thinker to come to that conclusion. British Army Chief of the General Staff Gen. Sir David Richards told The Sunday Telegraph:

If al-Qaeda and the Taliban believe they have defeated us – what next? Would they stop at Afghanistan? Pakistan is clearly a tempting target not least because of the fact that it is a nuclear-weaponed state and that is a terrifying prospect. Even if only a few of those (nuclear) weapons fell into their hands, believe me they would use them. The recent airlines plot has reminded us that there are people out there who would happily blow all of us up.

Former CentCom Commander Gen. Anthony Zinni told Face the Nation:

I think we have to be careful how long this goes on. It– it could be seen not only out there in the region by our allies even as the enemy as being indecisive–unable to make a decision. We’ve had a strategy since March. We have a general out there who is probably the best qualified we could have that’s telling us what we need on the ground to have the security space and the time to get those non-military things done. And I just don’t understand why we’re questioning that judgment at this point and I hope this doesn’t go on much longer.

British Shadow Defense Secretary Dr. Liam Fox told Heritage last month:

Were we to lose and be forced out of Afghanistan against our will, it would be a shot in the arm for every jihadist globally. It would send out the signal that we did not have the moral fortitude to see through what we believe to be a national security emergency. It would suggest that NATO, in its first great challenge since the end of the Cold War, did not have what it takes to see a difficult challenge through.

Chair of the House Armed Services Committee Ike Skelton (D-MO) told Face the Nation:

That’s the purpose of this entire mission. To quell the al Qaeda and to make sure that the Taliban is not there to invite them back. The war really didn’t start until March of this year when the president came forth with a strategy, frankly an excellent strategy. He chose General McChrystal who is the best in the business for this type of conflict. He asked General McChrystal for an assessment. He got that assessment. Of course that became known … it was public. And in essence he’s going to be asking for additional resources. … I back him up. I sent a letter to the president a number of days ago spelling out in great detail - some six pages of a letter - spelling out basically ‘Give the general what he needs.’

And Henry Kissinger writes in Newsweek:

The demand for an exit strategy is, of course, a metaphor for withdrawal, and withdrawal that is not accompanied by a willingness to sustain the outcome amounts to abandonment. Even so-called realists—like me—would gag at a tacit U.S. cooperation with the Taliban in the governance of Afghanistan.

Those in the chain of command in Afghanistan, each with outstanding qualifications, have all been recently appointed by the Obama administration. Rejecting their recommendations would be a triumph of domestic politics over strategic judgment.

The domestic politics are clear. MoveOn.org is asking their members to sign a petition calling for “a clear military exit strategy” and in the House, Rep. Barbara Lee (D-CA) has introduce a bill co-sponsored with 21 member of the Congressional Progressive Caucus that would prohibit an increase of troops in Afghanistan.

President Obama must ignore this pressure from his leftist base and give his military commanders the best chance for success by meeting their requests for the troops and resources necessary to fully implement the counterinsurgency strategy that his administration adopted in March. As General McChrystal warned: “We must show resolve. Uncertainty disheartens our allies, emboldens our foe.” President Obama must take the long view and avoid short-sighted policies that undermine our friends in Afghanistan and Pakistan, while encouraging our enemies.

    ---30---

QUICK HITS

    Recent Entries

    Links

    TEXT "follow HawaiiFreePress" to 40404

    Register to Vote

    2aHawaii

    808 Silent Majority

    808 State Update AM940

    ABCDEFG Blog

    ACA Signups Hawaii

    ACCE

    ALEC

    Alliance Defending Freedom

    Aloha Life Advocates

    Aloha Pregnancy Care Center

    American Council of Trustees and Alumni

    American Mothers of Hawaii

    AMVETS-Hawaii

    AntiPlanner

    Antonio Gramsci Reading List

    A Place for Women in Waipio

    Astronomy Hawaii

    Audit The Rail

    Ballotpedia Hawaii

    Better Hawaii 

    Blaisdell Memorial Project

    Broken Trust 

    Build More Hawaiian Homes Working Group

    CAFR Hawaii

    Castaway Conservative

    Children's Alliance Hawaii

    Children's Rights Institute

    ChinaTownWatch.com

    Christian Homeschoolers of Hawaii

    Citizens for Recall

    Cliff Slater's Second Opinion

    Coffee Break

    CSIS Pacific Forum

    DAR Hawaii

    DeedySupport.com

    DVids Hawaii

    E Hana Kakou Kelii Akina

    E Māua Ola i Moku o Keawe

    Farmers For Choice Hawaii

    FIRE

    Fix Oahu!

    Follow the Money Hawaii

    Frank in Hawaii

    Front Page Magazine

    Frontline: The Fixers

    Genetic Literacy Project

    Get Off Your Butts!

    God, Freedom, America

    Grassroot Institute

    Habele.org

    Hawaii Aganst Assisted Suicide

    Hawaii Aquarium Fish Report

    Hawaii Aviation Preservation Society

    Hawaii Catholic TV

    Hawaii Christian Coalition

    Hawaii Cigar Association

    Hawaii Coalition Against Legalized Gambling

    Hawaii ConCon Info

    Hawaii Credit Union Watch

    Hawaii Crime Victims' Rights

    Hawaii Crop Improvement Association

    Hawaii Debt Clock

    Hawaii Defending Marriage

    Hawaii Defense Foundation

    Hawaii Families for Educational Choice

    Hawaii Family Advocates

    Hawaii Family Forum

    Hawaii Farmers and Ranchers United

    Hawaii Farmer's Daughter

    Hawaii Federalist Society

    Hawaii Federation of Republican Women

    Hawaii Firearm Community

    Hawaii Fishermen's Alliance

    Hawaii Future Project

    Hawaii Gathering of Eagles

    Hawaii History Blog

    Hawaii Homeschool Association

    Hawaii Jihadi Trial

    Hawaii March for Life

    Hawaii Meth Project

    Hawaii's Partnership for Appropriate & Compassionate Care

    Hawaii Public Charter School Network

    Hawaii Rifle Association

    Hawaii Right to Life -- Big Island

    Hawaii Right to Life -- Oahu

    Hawaii Shield Law Coalition

    Hawaii Shippers Council

    Hawaii Smokers Alliance

    Hawaii State Data Lab

    Hawaii Together

    Heritage Foundation

    HI Coalition Against Legalized Gambling

    HIEC.Coop 

    HiFiCo

    Hiram Fong Papers

    Homeschool Legal Defense Hawaii

    Honolulu Homeless Crisis

    Honolulu Navy League

    Honolulu Traffic

    Horns of Jericho Blog

    House Minority Blog

    House Republican Caucus YouTube

    HPACC

    Hump Day Report

    I Vote Hawaii

    If Hawaii News

    Imua TMT

    Inouye-Kwock, NYT 1992

    Inside the Nature Conservancy

    Inverse Condemnation

    Investigative Project on Terrorism

    Iowa Meets Maui

    Jackson v Abercrombie

    Jihad Watch

    July 4 in Hawaii

    Kahle v New Hope

    Kakaako Cares

    Kau TEA Party

    Kauai Co GOP

    Keep Hawaii's Heroes

    KeyWiki

    Land and Power in Hawaii

    Legislative Committee Analysis Tool

    Lessons in Firearm Education

    Lingle Years

    Malulani Foundation

    Managed Care Matters -- Hawaii

    Malama Pregnancy Center of Maui

    Mauna Kea Recreational Users Group

    MentalIllnessPolicy.org

    Middle East Forum--The Legal Project

    Mililani Conservatives for Change

    Military Home Educators' Network Oahu

    Missile Defense Advocacy

    MIS Veterans Hawaii

    Muslim Brotherhood in America

    NAMI Hawaii

    NARTH

    Natatorium.org

    National Christian Foundation Hawaii

    National Parents Org Hawaii

    National Wind Watch

    New Zeal

    NFIB Hawaii News

    No GMO Means No Aloha

    Northwest Economic Policy Seminar

    Not Dead Yet, Hawaii

    Now What I Really Think

    NRA-ILA Hawaii

    Oahu Alternative Transport

    ObamaCare Abortion Hawaii

    Obookiah

    OHA Lies

    Opt Out Today

    OurFutureHawaii.com

    Pacific Aviation Museum

    Patients Rights Council Hawaii

    PEACE Hawaii

    People vs Machine

    Pritchett Cartoons 

    Pro-GMO Hawaii

    P.U.E.O.

    RailRipoff.com

    Rental by Owner Awareness Assn

    Republican Party -- Hawaii State

    Research Institute for Hawaii USA

    Rick Hamada Show

    RJ Rummel

    Robotics Organizing Committee

    School Choice in Hawaii

    SenatorFong.com

    SIFE Remington

    SIFE W. Oahu 

    Sink the Jones Act

    Smart About Marijuana--Hawaii

    St Marianne Cope

    State Budget Solutions Hawaii

    State Policy Network

    Statehood for Guam

    Tax Foundation of Hawaii

    The Harriet Tubman Agenda

    The Long War Journal

    The Real Hanabusa

    Time Out Honolulu

    Trustee Akina KWO Columns

    Truth About Trade & Technology - Hawaii

    UCC Truths

    Union Members Know Your Rights

    US Tax Foundation Hawaii Info

    Valor in the Pacific

    VAREP Honolulu

    Waagey.org

    West Maui Taxpayers Association

    What Natalie Thinks

    Whole Life Hawaii

    Yes2TMT