Saturday, March 28, 2020
Hawai'i Free Press

Current Articles | Archives

Saturday, December 15, 2012
Guam: Mayor Seizes Neighbor's Land
By Robert Thomas @ 12:29 AM :: 4628 Views :: National News, Land Use

New Cert Petition: Private Purpose Pretext In Economic Development Takings

by Robert Thomas,

In the nearly eight years since the Supreme Court's infamous decision in Kelo v. City of New London, the Court has yet to provide any clarification about what it meant when it said that a taking will not survive public use analysis when the proffered justification is a pretext to private benefit. Despite massive uncertainty and conflicting rulings from the lower courts about how to apply this standard and more than a few requests for guidance (including our own), the Court has not taken up a case.

Here's the latest, a cert petition out of Guam, that we think stands a pretty decent chance to grabbing the Court's attention. The Question Presented sets out the facts well, so we won't go into the details of the case, but let's just say that this condemnation doesn't just seem to lack a public purpose, or appear that it was for a predominantly private purpose, it looks out-and-out corrupt and purely for a private gain, cloaked in the veneer of economic development:

Mr. Ilagan owns land on which he owns and operates an apartment building. His neighbors—the Ungactas—own an adjacent, residentially zoned lot. In 1981, the Ungacta property lacked access to a road. That same year, while Mr. Ungacta was Mayor of the City of Agana, the Ungactas appraised a part of Mr. Ilagan’s property that had access to a road and which was used to provide parking for tenants of the Ilagan apartment. Soon after, the government condemned the appraised area, paying for it with compensation supplied by the Ungactas, and transferred it to the Ungactas.

The government justified the property transfer as an "economic development" measure occurring under the "Agana Plan," a post-World War Two redevelopment plan enacted to reconfigure irregular lot lines in Agana. The Plan had been defunct for seven years prior to the 1981 Ilagan taking. When active, it did not contemplate a single lot taking and had never been used that way. No other lots were taken under purported authority of the Plan at the time of the Ilagan taking. In the 30 years since then, the Plan has never been used to take any property. Although the Guam trial court held the taking unconstitutional, the Guam Supreme Court reversed. At the urging of the Real Parties in Interest Ungactas (the Government did not appeal), that court applied a standard of "judicial deference" pursuant to Kelo v. City of New London, 545 U.S. 469 (2005), and held the taking served a valid public purpose.

The Questions Presented are:

1. Does the Public Use Clause of the Fifth Amendment prohibit a taking which the government claims is for economic development, when the evidence shows it is actually designed to give property to a favored private party for that party’s own private purposes and enjoyment?

2. Does the doctrine of Kelo v. City of New London, 545 U.S. 469 (2005), according deference to a legislative claim that a taking serves a public economic purpose, apply when there is a real risk that the taking serves a private purpose because (a) the taking was initiated and funded by the private party who acquired the property; (b) that party was identified before the taking, (c) the taking produces no meaningful public benefit, but (d) clearly advances the private goals of the property transferee?

This reminds of a recent decision from the Pennsylvania Supreme Court holding that a private road statute (which allows a landlocked property owner to petition for condemnation of a private access road over a neighbor's property) might violate the Public Use Clause.

The Guam petition seems like a good vehicle for the U.S. Supreme Court to revisit the pretext issue, should it desire to do so. And we suppose that is the big question since the issue is otherwise certworthy by virtue of the diverging and conflicting lower courts: does the Court want to wade back into the Public Use issue?

Petition for a Writ of Certiorari, Ilagan v. Ungacta, No. ___ (Dec. 10, 2012)



TEXT "follow HawaiiFreePress" to 40404

Register to Vote


808 Silent Majority

808 State Update AM940


ACA Signups Hawaii



Alliance Defending Freedom

Aloha Life Advocates

Aloha Pregnancy Care Center

American Council of Trustees and Alumni

American Mothers of Hawaii



Antonio Gramsci Reading List

A Place for Women in Waipio

Astronomy Hawaii

Audit The Rail

Ballotpedia Hawaii

Better Hawaii 

Blaisdell Memorial Project

Broken Trust 

Build More Hawaiian Homes Working Group

CAFR Hawaii

Castaway Conservative

Children's Alliance Hawaii

Children's Rights Institute

Christian Homeschoolers of Hawaii

Citizens for Recall

Cliff Slater's Second Opinion

Coffee Break

CSIS Pacific Forum

DAR Hawaii

DVids Hawaii

E Hana Kakou Kelii Akina

E Māua Ola i Moku o Keawe

Farmers For Choice Hawaii


Fix Oahu!

Follow the Money Hawaii

Frank in Hawaii

Front Page Magazine

Frontline: The Fixers

Genetic Literacy Project

Get Off Your Butts!

God, Freedom, America

Grassroot Institute

Hawaii Aganst Assisted Suicide

Hawaii Aquarium Fish Report

Hawaii Aviation Preservation Society

Hawaii Catholic TV

Hawaii Christian Coalition

Hawaii Cigar Association

Hawaii Coalition Against Legalized Gambling

Hawaii ConCon Info

Hawaii Credit Union Watch

Hawaii Crime Victims' Rights

Hawaii Crop Improvement Association

Hawaii Debt Clock

Hawaii Defending Marriage

Hawaii Defense Foundation

Hawaii Families for Educational Choice

Hawaii Family Advocates

Hawaii Family Forum

Hawaii Farmers and Ranchers United

Hawaii Farmer's Daughter

Hawaii Federalist Society

Hawaii Federation of Republican Women

Hawaii Firearm Community

Hawaii Fishermen's Alliance

Hawaii Future Project

Hawaii Gathering of Eagles

Hawaii History Blog

Hawaii Homeschool Association

Hawaii Jihadi Trial

Hawaii March for Life

Hawaii Meth Project

Hawaii's Partnership for Appropriate & Compassionate Care

Hawaii Public Charter School Network

Hawaii Rifle Association

Hawaii Right to Life -- Big Island

Hawaii Right to Life -- Oahu

Hawaii Shield Law Coalition

Hawaii Shippers Council

Hawaii Smokers Alliance

Hawaii State Data Lab

Hawaii Together

Heritage Foundation

HI Coalition Against Legalized Gambling



Hiram Fong Papers

Homeschool Legal Defense Hawaii

Honolulu Homeless Crisis

Honolulu Navy League

Honolulu Traffic

Horns of Jericho Blog

House Minority Blog

House Republican Caucus YouTube


Hump Day Report

I Vote Hawaii

If Hawaii News

Imua TMT

Inouye-Kwock, NYT 1992

Inside the Nature Conservancy

Inverse Condemnation

Investigative Project on Terrorism

Iowa Meets Maui

Jackson v Abercrombie

Jihad Watch

Judgepedia Hawaii

July 4 in Hawaii

Kahle v New Hope

Kakaako Cares

Kau TEA Party

Kauai Co GOP

Keep Hawaii's Heroes


Land and Power in Hawaii

Legislative Committee Analysis Tool

Lessons in Firearm Education

Lingle Years

Malulani Foundation

Managed Care Matters -- Hawaii

Malama Pregnancy Center of Maui

Mauna Kea Recreational Users Group

Middle East Forum--The Legal Project

Mililani Conservatives for Change

Military Home Educators' Network Oahu

Missile Defense Advocacy

MIS Veterans Hawaii

Muslim Brotherhood in America

NAMI Hawaii


National Christian Foundation Hawaii

National Parents Org Hawaii

National Wind Watch

New Zeal

NFIB Hawaii News

No GMO Means No Aloha

Northwest Economic Policy Seminar

Not Dead Yet, Hawaii

Now What I Really Think

NRA-ILA Hawaii

Oahu Alternative Transport

ObamaCare Abortion Hawaii


OHA Lies

Opt Out Today

Pacific Aviation Museum

Patients Rights Council Hawaii

PEACE Hawaii

People vs Machine

Pritchett Cartoons 

Pro-GMO Hawaii


Rental by Owner Awareness Assn

Republican Party -- Hawaii State

Research Institute for Hawaii USA

Rick Hamada Show

RJ Rummel

Robotics Organizing Committee

School Choice in Hawaii

SIFE Remington

SIFE W. Oahu 

Sink the Jones Act

Smart About Marijuana--Hawaii

St Marianne Cope

State Budget Solutions Hawaii

State Policy Network

Statehood for Guam

Tax Foundation of Hawaii

The Harriet Tubman Agenda

The Long War Journal

The Real Hanabusa

Time Out Honolulu

Trustee Akina KWO Columns

Truth About Trade & Technology - Hawaii

UCC Truths

Union Members Know Your Rights

US Tax Foundation Hawaii Info

Valor in the Pacific

VAREP Honolulu

West Maui Taxpayers Association

What Natalie Thinks

Whole Life Hawaii