Report by Bill 9 Temporary Investigative Group to be released Oct. 14

News Release from Maui County Council, Oct 10, 2025

(CLUE: PRP operative Uʻu-Hodgins is the swing vote on Bill 9.)

WAILUKU, Hawaiʻi (Oct. 10, 2025)— Councilmember Nohelani Uʻu-Hodgins announced today that a report from the temporary investigative group she led on policy responses to the possible phasing out of transient vacation rental uses in Apartment Districts will be released Tuesday.

She said the group’s report will be presented at a Housing and Land Use Committee meeting in the Council Chamber and online at 9 a.m. Tuesday under a process set Aug. 20. The committee formed the Bill 9 TIG after earlier recommending passage of revised version of Bill 9 (2025), Mayor Richard T. Bissen, Jr.’s proposal to phase out TVRs as permitted uses in the A-1 and A-2 zoning districts, Uʻu-Hodgins said.

“The Bill 9 TIG allowed members to conduct a more in-depth examination of how phasing out TVRs in Apartment Districts may impact the surrounding communities and the county as a whole,” said Uʻu-Hodgins, who holds the seat for the Makawao-Haʻikū-Pāʻia residency area. “The temporary investigative group is presenting its findings to support the council in its policy-making work and to review the Department of Planning’s processes for zoning and other land-use changes.”

Testimony will be accepted by the committee at Tuesday’s meeting. But, under state Sunshine Law, no deliberations or discussions on the report can be held at the meeting. The committee will meet at a later date to discuss the group’s recommendations, Uʻu-Hodgins said.

The temporary investigative group was tasked by the committee with:

• identifying properties where continuing TVR uses may be appropriate,
• summarizing forecasted economic and social impacts and
• suggesting zoning bills and County Code improvements if Bill 9 is enacted.

(TRANSLATION: Maybe we will steal only some of the Minatoya list properties.)

Bill 9 TIG discussions over the last month included county personnel, individuals with expertise on TVR uses, loan officers, realtors and housing advocates, Uʻu-Hodgins said.

The Bill 9 TIG—which is being dissolved after presentation of its report—included Councilmembers Tamara Paltin, Tom Cook and Shane M. Sinenci.

A committee report recommending passage on first reading of Bill 9, CD1 (2025), based on the committee’s vote July 24, is being scheduled for an upcoming Maui County Council meeting. The county Department of the Corporation Counsel approved the bill as to form and legality Wednesday.

Tuesday’s committee meeting will be livestreamed on Akakū Channel 53, at MauiCounty.us and on the council’s Facebook and YouTube pages. For more information, call the Office of Council Services at (808) 270-7664.

---30---

MN: Investigative report on proposal to rollback TVRs to be released next week

REALITY: Meet the Meth Gang Behind ‘Lahaina Strong’