Permission to Fix Your Own Roof: Kaua’i Ordinance 1187 vs Hurricane Lowell Victims
by Randy S Weir
The roof of a house on Kauaʻi's south shore leaks, siding or a door is damaged after Hurricane Lowell:
A homeowner a mile inland can repair the same damage tomorrow, with no permit, no fee and no inspection. The County has said so in every recovery update it has issued since September (County of Kauaʻi, Nov. 18 update).
The shoreline homeowner has to ask the County Planning Department first. Without that approval, work done in the ‘shoreline setback’ of up to 500 feet “may be subject to violations." (County of Kauaʻi)
That warning has real force. Under the County's fine schedule, a first zoning violation can cost up to $10,000. A second within five years can cost up to $15,000, and a third up to $25,000 (County fine schedule filed with the Hawaiʻi Coastal Zone Management Program). The state law the County also enforces allows fines of up to $100,000, plus $10,000 for every day a violation continues (Hawaiʻi Office of Planning).
These penalties might be suitable for the dumping of toxic waste, yet they hang over a family that replaces storm-damaged siding or replaces an AC condenser without the right paperwork.
Officials and activists have been open about the larger goal. Chip Fletcher, Dean of the School of Ocean and Earth Science and Technology at the University of Hawai‘i Mānoa says, “It’s very important that we …use our rules and policies to roll back the existing development on the shoreline.” (Civil Beat) Kaua’i County Planning Director Ka‘āina Hull says that once the shoreline reaches a house, the house "becomes state property and must be removed." (Civil Beat) The text of Ordinance 1187 requires owners who rebuild substantially on eroding lots to sign recorded agreements to "retreat, relocate, or remove" their homes at their own expense. They must also give up any right to seawall protection for the life of the structure (Ordinance 1187, §8-27.7(b)).
Shoreline: Repairs now need prior approval
Ordinance 1187, signed March 30, 2026, rewrote Kauaʻi's shoreline setback law (Star-Advertiser legal notice). Its own findings say it creates "revised requirements for shoreline property owners seeking to repair existing structures" (Ordinance 1187). In practice, any structure potentially within the shoreline setback area must first get a "shoreline setback determination" from the Planning Director (Ordinance 1187, §8-27.8).
In a free society, keeping up your own home should be the clearest, most fundamental exercise of property rights there is. Under Ordinance 1187 home maintenance and repair become a privilege the government grants—that is you need a permission slip to take care of your own property. A repair is allowed only if the Planning Director agrees that it meets the County's definition of "repair" (Ordinance 1187, §8-27.7(a)(6)(D)). The homeowner never has a ‘right’ to fix their own house.
Shoreline: The County audits your receipts
The ordinance requires a lot of paperwork before a shoreline owner may replace a window...or perform basic maintenance, like painting. The owner must submit a professional appraisal of the house, minus depreciation. The owner must also submit an itemized "Non-Substantial Improvement Job Cost Breakdown Worksheet." It covers everything from masonry and drywall to "flooring, appliances, cabinetry, and all labor." Then the owner must sign a declaration agreeing that these numbers can be reviewed after the work is finished (Ordinance 1187, §8-27.7(a)(6)(E)).
The review doesn't end there. The owner must tell the County when the job is done. Until the owner does, the Department "shall consider this repair project still ongoing." The Director may demand receipts for every item, either during the work or within 60 days after. If the receipts can't be produced, "the Director may establish the fair market cost" on the County's own terms (Ordinance 1187, §8-27.7(a)(6)(E)(iv)–(v)).
So the government can price your private home improvements by its own estimates. It can keep a project open indefinitely. And it can reopen the books after the work is done. That is not oversight of construction: It is ongoing financial surveillance of a household. If the County can do this to shoreline setback properties up to 500’ inland, then they can do it to anybody by simply creating new rules to enforce.
Shoreline: The County's own math decides what counts
Everything turns on a single number. Repairs that add up to 50% or more of the house's pre-construction market value over any 10-year period count as a "substantial improvement" (Ordinance 1187, §8-27.2).
Past that line, the project stops being a repair, and the Director must start enforcement (Ordinance 1187, §8-27.7(a)(6)(E)(vi)). The penalty is severe: the County can require the improvements removed, or the whole house moved out of the setback (Civil Beat).
Consider what that means after a hurricane. A storm doesn't care about a ten-year cost ledger. One bad night can push a family that has spent years on a new roof, a water heater and termite repairs over the line. Then the house they were trying to save is in jeopardy. The rule punishes owners for the bad luck of living where storms hit.
Shoreline: Public notice for private repairs
The ordinance also requires public display. No repair may begin until the owner puts up a sign at least 24 by 36 inches, white with black lettering, within ten feet of the public road. It must show the setback determination number, the owner's name, address and phone number (doxing anyone?), and the permit numbers. It has to go up five days before work starts and stay up until the job is finished. Failing to keep the sign up "shall constitute a violation" (Ordinance 1187,§8-27.8(c)(12)).
Every repair application is also posted on a public website and opened to a 30-day public comment period (Ordinance 1187, §8-27.8(c)(5)). The ordinance exempts public utilities and government infrastructure from this waiting period. Homeowners get no such exemption.
So, your neighbors and any activist on the island are invited to comment on, and thereby police, whether you may fix your own lanai. Your name and phone number are posted by the road while you do it.
Shoreline: The Director acts as prosecutor and judge
The ordinance's enforcement section takes away the protections a citizen would expect. Once a removal order is issued, an appeal does not pause it "unless specifically ordered by a court of competent jurisdiction" (Ordinance 1187, §8-27.11(e)). To collect a fine in court, the Director "need only show" three things: a notice was served, the time to request a hearing passed or a hearing was held, and the fine was not paid (Ordinance 1187, §8-27.11(c)).
The ordinance also adds language to tear down unpermitted improvement not just unpermitted buildings. It flatly bars the Planning Commission from granting a variance for structures "constructed without valid permits" (Ordinance 1187, §8-27.10(j), §8-27.11(b)(2)). It even states that "economic hardship" from small lot size does not count as hardship (Ordinance 1187, §8-27.10(d)). The owners with the least room and the least money get the least mercy.
Even disaster relief holds back shoreline owners
After Hurricane Lowell, the Mayor's emergency orders suspended permit requirements across the island. Shoreline owners got only a partial break: they may file the required shoreline survey up to 12 months after applying. But the County "reserves the right to issue an order to dismantle and remove any repairs and impose any penalties" if the survey never arrives (Second Supplemental Emergency Proclamation). Even emergency relief for shoreline families comes with the threat that their repairs could be torn down.
A small problem, a sweeping remedy
What justified all of this? The Planning Director told Civil Beat the department had received seven complaints in two years about coastal homes doing more work than allowed. He pointed mainly to vacation rentals in Wainiha and Hāʻena on the North Shore (Civil Beat). Seven complaints, mostly about one stretch of the North Shore, now place every shoreline household on the island under appraisals, receipt audits, public signs and five-figure fines.
Even supporters of tighter rules raised concerns. Pacific Resource Partnership represents 6,000 union carpenters and 250 contractors. It warned that the fixed $125,000 survey trigger in Ordinance 1187 ignores property size, value and inflation and "could disproportionately affect modest homes." It also said that retreat-and-removal agreements need "objective, verifiable triggers" (Civil Beat). The Council passed the bill 7–0 anyway (Star-Advertiser legal notice).
Put plainly: the County does not want shoreline homes repaired. It wants them to wear out under the weight of paperwork, cost audits and fines until the sea, or the state, takes them. It works by making ordinary life depend on permission, then making permission conditional, revocable and enforced through fear and financial threats. Ordinance 1187 does this to a whole class of residents:
· Basic upkeep becomes something you need County permission to do.
· Home repair spending is subject to open-ended government audit and repricing.
· Repairs are posted publicly and opened to activists’ and neighbors’ objections.
· A single official decides, keeps the file open, and enforces the result. Removal orders take effect immediately, even under appeal.
· Repeated violations can bring fines of $25,000, and state penalties reach $100,000.
· All of it is aimed at the stated goal of eventually getting rid of the homes themselves.
Hawaiʻi has every right to protect its beaches. But every shoreline family is now living by government permission slip in homes they supposedly own. ‘Protecting beaches’ doesn't require treating a retired couple in Poʻipū like suspects because they replace their storm shutters.
The County Council should amend Ordinance 1187 to restore an absolute right to maintain and repair lawfully built homes, no matter where they are.