Saturday, November 21, 2026
Hawai'i Free Press

Current Articles | Archives | Search

Saturday, November 21, 2026

With Tax Hike Coming, DoH Refuses to Reveal Where Your ‘Recycling’ Really Ends Up

By Andrew Walden @ 3:24 PM :: 123 Views :: Environment, Ethics, Small Business, Taxes
 

by Andrew Walden

The Legislature, in 2027, will once again be asked to increase the HI-5 bottle tax, imposed on all plastic containers, from $0.06 to $0.10. 

Why should Hawai’i residents and small businesses pay even more? 

Here is EEP Chair, Rep Nicole Lowen, September 24, 2026, saying she wants to know how much you are actually participating:

“It would be interesting to know what percent of our customers who are paying 6 cents at the register are actually going to get their 5 cents back as an individual versus the curbside recycling program where they’re basically donating it to the City and County of Honolulu. Understanding those statistics would be critical to being able to improve and operate a good program. … I’m disappointed to not have a better understanding of that number if I’m being honest.”

In other words, yes, it really is all about getting you to fulfill the rituals of the eco-religion.

Looking Back

Akamai readers may remember January 1, 2018, the fraudsters were thrown into disarray when China began refusing shipments of plastic ‘recyclables’ under 'Operation National Sword.’  Southeast Asian countries quickly followed suit fearing redirected shipments would produce an even more massive influx of foreign garbage into illegal jungle dump sites. 

The effect was felt quickly in Hawai’i.  On October 16, 2019 the Hawai’i County Department of Environmental Management began refusing all plastic paper and carboard. 

Big Island Now, Oct 15, 2019, reported:

Department of Environmental Management Director Bill Kucharski on Tuesday afternoon provided a briefing to the Hawai‘i County Council on changes to the county’s recycling policy, which have caused unrest about the future of the local environment islandwide.

Commonly recycled items such as plastic bottles or plastic containers of any kind, newspaper, office paper, cereal boxes and all other non-corrugated cardboard will no longer be accepted at transfer stations anywhere on Hawai‘i Island as of Wednesday, Oct. 16, 2019.

The decision comes on the heels of what the county has described as “significant decreases in global recycling markets,” namely in China and other Southeast Asian countries where Hawai‘i’s recyclable waste has been most commonly sold….

China, formerly a top buyer in the market, announced in 2017 plans to up its contamination standards on recyclables to 1%. Industry experts like Jerry Powell, executive editor at Resource Recycling Inc., said those standards, which went into effect in January 2018, are essentially impossible to meet….

Kucharski said the problem of what do about recyclables in Hawai‘i is more systemic and long-standing than negative economic developments over just the past two years. The state and county’s policies, he said, have more or less equated to an “out of sight, out of mind” strategy.

“I have a problem justifying shipping waste products 3,000 miles in either direction with the hope that they’ll be recycled (by whoever we sell them to) and calling that sustainable,” Kucharski said. “It’s like covering your eyes because you don’t like what you’re seeing.”

Flash forward seven years. 

Where are Hawaii’s plastic ‘recyclables’ being sent today?  At a September 24, 2026 hearing of the House Committee on Energy and Environmental Protection (EEP), Lane Otsu of the Hawaii Department of Health Office of Solid Waste Management told legislators, “all of the collected containers are sent to out-of-state facilities for recycling.”

Given the decades-long record of plastic recycling fraud, the obvious question is: What are those “out-of-state facilities”?

Hawai’i Free Press filed a UIPA request with the Hawaii DoH September 29, 2026 seeking:

“Copies of all ‘corroborating weight reports obtained from end-user recycling facilities’ as that term is used in State Auditor Report No. 25-08 (pg 14-15), for plastic deposit beverage container material for the period July 1, 2023 through June 30, 2026.”

State and County agencies are legally required to respond to UIPA requests within 10 working days.  But the initial response from DoH was a month of silence.   After a follow-up request to DoH, DOH UIPA officer Amy Liana handed off her responsibility to the very same Lane Otsu who had testified at the EEP hearing.  Otsu first claimed he was working on it, followed by a week of silence.  Then he claimed that the ‘estimated cost’ to fulfill the request would be $1,675, due to the need to manually copy and redact 9,600 pages of paper records.

Then, citing HRS §92F-13(3), Otsu stated redactions would hide: 

“Confidential business information including identification of the broker and destination recycling facility. The confidential will be redacted.  The identities of the broker and recycling facility are considered confidential because they are the source of competitive advantage for each Certified Redemption Center.”  

In plain language: After six weeks of obfuscation, DoH is refusing to reveal where these so-called recyclables end up.  And they want $1,675 to do it.

The DOH website says these records are already maintained in Excel format.

Given the long history of fraud in plastic recycling, secrecy logically begets skepticism.  With China and South East Asia out of the picture, why is DoH trying to prevent the public from finding the new “out of sight, out of mind” destinations?

---30---

BACKGROUND:

Comments